Comments on: Design in the Wild: American Science and Surplus - a folksonomy gone bad http://www.everydayux.com/2008/03/28/design-in-the-wild-american-science-and-surplus-a-folksonomy-gone-bad/ Tue, 07 Oct 2008 15:32:01 +0000 http://wordpress.org/?v=2.6.1 By: Noah Mittman http://www.everydayux.com/2008/03/28/design-in-the-wild-american-science-and-surplus-a-folksonomy-gone-bad/#comment-112 Noah Mittman Sun, 30 Mar 2008 04:45:14 +0000 http://www.everydayux.com/2008/03/28/design-in-the-wild-american-science-and-surplus-a-folksonomy-gone-bad/#comment-112 I love how this just looks like graffiti. People on the site are using the folksonomy to bookmark things. They're literally tagging their name to items so they can find them later; most items only have two or three and they side towards initials or usernames more than dictionary words. This is far more an example of tagging being unnecessary in the first place (there is a tight taxonomy of products present on the site) than it is the audience not knowing how to use it, as there is little to no obvious value in using it properly: what else is there to say about a "Digital Multimeter" categorized in "Electrical Parts > Gauges & Meters" that isn't already evident in all that text? Clearly, the feature that should have been developed first was a Wish List. I love how this just looks like graffiti.
People on the site are using the folksonomy to bookmark things.
They’re literally tagging their name to items so they can find them later; most items only have two or three and they side towards initials or usernames more than dictionary words.

This is far more an example of tagging being unnecessary in the first place (there is a tight taxonomy of products present on the site) than it is the audience not knowing how to use it, as there is little to no obvious value in using it properly: what else is there to say about a “Digital Multimeter” categorized in “Electrical Parts > Gauges & Meters” that isn’t already evident in all that text? Clearly, the feature that should have been developed first was a Wish List.

]]> By: kipbot http://www.everydayux.com/2008/03/28/design-in-the-wild-american-science-and-surplus-a-folksonomy-gone-bad/#comment-110 kipbot Sat, 29 Mar 2008 12:43:51 +0000 http://www.everydayux.com/2008/03/28/design-in-the-wild-american-science-and-surplus-a-folksonomy-gone-bad/#comment-110 Some friends at Yahoo and Amazon have indicated that despite the digerati's fascination with tags, people have no idea how to use them or what they mean. Your screenshot shows a lot of just plain keyboard junk, but people tend to write sentences, phrases, captions, dates into these boxes as well. Larger companies can screen out the articles, catch the dates, strip the punctuation, and clean some of them up, but we're a ways away from non-digerati folksonomoies. Some friends at Yahoo and Amazon have indicated that despite the digerati’s fascination with tags, people have no idea how to use them or what they mean. Your screenshot shows a lot of just plain keyboard junk, but people tend to write sentences, phrases, captions, dates into these boxes as well. Larger companies can screen out the articles, catch the dates, strip the punctuation, and clean some of them up, but we’re a ways away from non-digerati folksonomoies.

]]>